Monday, June 19, 2023

Vileness

Man, Kim Ogg had to be missing her some Dudegoggles today.  

Ever since former Harris County District Attorney's Office spokesperson Dane Schiller left the Office (and the country!) following his disastrous appearance as a witness in the Guajuardo hearing last year, it looks like Boss Ogg has been managing her own Twitter account.

And if today's events are any indicator, suffice it to say that things are not going well.

It started off with a seemingly non-Ogg-related tweet from June 6th by a Twitter account called "Urban Reform" that had made note of a recent heated exchange between County Judge Lina Hidalgo and County Commissioner Adrien Garcia.  The original tweet seemed to be more of an observation that the event had happened and did not appear to cast judgment on Hidalgo.

However, as we all know, one cannot say the words "Lina Hidalgo" without awakening the hordes of Lina-haters that seem to cruise the waters of Twitter like a killer whale looking for a wounded seal.  This post was no exception as many pearl-clutching, anti-Hidalgo tweeters came out to illustrate that never in their ENTIRE LIVES had they heard someone drop a (gasp) "F-Bomb" in public, and certainly not a  (swoon) woman!  One of the ultra-sheltered tweeters was a lady whom I have met (and actually enjoyed talking to in person) who posted under the handle of "Michelle GCR."

Now, Michelle is not a big fan of Judge Hidalgo and never has been.  So, it was no surprise to me that Michelle's tweet in response to Urban Reform's tweet was short and sweet:  "She is vile."

What was surprising to me, however, was to see that Kim Ogg retweeted what Michelle had said.


So, if you are unfamiliar with Twitter etiquette, when one "retweets" another's "tweet," they are normally endorsing it and the sentiment behind it.  There may be exceptions, but Twitter gives a user the option to comment along with that retweet (i.e., "this is wrong" when retweeting something you actually disagree with).

But Kim Ogg just retweeted the sentiment that Lina Hidalgo was, in fact, vile.

So, I posted my own tweet, calling attention to what Kim Ogg had retweeted, and some members of the Horde of Hidalgo Haters turned their attention toward me.   Most accused me of being a Lina Hidalgo apologist/fan club member.  I've certainly been called worse, but the truth is that my feelings are probably best described as "okay."  I voted for Ed Emmett over her in 2018 because I thought he was an amazing County Judge.  I did, however, vote for Hidalgo over Alexandra del Moral Mealer, because I felt that Mealer was an election-denying, anti-vaxxing, right-wing kook.  I've disagreed with Hidalgo on some issues and agreed with her on others.  I don't agree with any of the racist or sexist vitriol that so many of her detractors aim at her.

Defending Hidalgo wasn't the reason for me pointing out Kim's retweet.  The issue was that Kim was sharing her personal distaste for someone that she has been actively investigating for a couple of years now.  This wasn't about the job Lina Hidalgo was doing.  It was about the job that Kim Ogg is, yet again, not doing.

A prosecutor's job is to seek justice.  If you don't believe me, just watch jury selection in a criminal case and they'll be happy to tell you.  They seek justice and the implication is that they do so without any type of personal bias or other dog in the hunt.  There's also an implication in there somewhere that a prosecutor isn't supposed to seek justice for media attention or votes, but Kim Ogg has never really adhered to that little unwritten rule.   From her prosecution of Arkema to HPD's narcotics squad to Dr. Hasan Gokal to three staffers in Judge Hidalgo's office, Kim has proven time and again her fondness for charging people with crimes for headlines.  

But with Kim's retweet of Michelle's "She is vile" message, our elected D.A. is showing a strong indication that her motivation for her investigations into Hidalgo and her staff is more than just capitalizing on the anti-Lina Hidalgo sentiment.  Apparently, there's some personal animosity mixed in there, too.

That's no shock to those of us who follow Harris County politics.  Ogg and Hidalgo are clearly political enemies, and Ogg has misleadingly accused Hidalgo of "defunding" the D.A.'s Office on multiple well-publicized occasions.  Hidalgo, as mentioned above, dropped an F-bomb when accusing Commissioner Garcia of being too closely aligned with Ogg.  Both are public officials and both are entitled to their opinions.  They are free to disagree and even fight with each other.

But only one of them has the power to potentially have the other investigated and prosecuted.  

And Kim Ogg's office has done just that for well over a year now.  In an "investigation" into Hidalgo's Office, there were media leaks right and left before three of Hidalgo's staffers were indicted (on what I personally believe are absolutely unsubstantiated charges based on my knowledge of the case).  In the aftermath, Hidalgo expressed concerns that based on Ogg's hatred of her that she (Hidalgo) would be indicted next.  Kim's retweeting of "She is vile." gives fuel to that fire and it's not what society expects from a prosecutor who is supposed to keep Justice blind to personal animosities.  It's a bad look and Kim knows that.  

How do we know that?  Because of what happened next . . .

After attention was brought to the retweet, Kim's Twitter account posted a laughably lame explanation that her account had been "hacked." 


Some were skeptical.


As is typical when Kim Ogg steps in dog crap, she blames someone else.  It couldn't possibly be that she was so stupid to put a stunning lack of ethics on such display, could it?  Of course not.  She had obviously been hacked.

If you are feeling like you are experiencing deja vu all over again, you aren't going crazy.  Remember this fun story from three years ago?  It may sound eerily familiar.   The short version goes like this - Kim Ogg sends out an e-mail to all prosecutors looking for "volunteers" to help at an event where she hands out free stuff to potential voters.  Her e-mail notes that their participation will be reflected in their evaluation.


And when some blogger points out on Twitter that perhaps coercing your employees to work a campaign event for you under threat of retaliation is completely illegal isn't a good look for an elected official, suddenly it turns out to be an unauthorized person using Kim's account without permission.


Amazing!

It seems to me that Kim Ogg's retweet of her thoughts on the "vileness" of Lina Hidalgo might become an interesting exhibit in that Motion to Recuse that was filed last year.

Maybe for once, somebody might actually hold our District Attorney accountable for the extra-judicial statements she makes about the cases her Office is handling.

12 comments:

Anonymous said...

It's a pity that both sides can't lose.

Lee said...

I voted for and used to work for Kim Ogg when she was in private practice and still remain friends with her. I have often wondered why she wanted to become the district attorney (managing staff, paper shuffling running budgets) given her skill set. I have seen her in action and she is a great trial attorney and I believe that she belongs not in administration but on the front lines in court prosecuting our city's most violent or defending our city's most vulnerable. I feel like she had some policy changes that she wanted to make in the district attorney's office but I feel like she makes a far better trail attorney than administrator.

I have met Lina Hidalgo before and ran into her downtown last week and she has always been nice to me. One of my best friends Kathryn Kase works for her and the situation in Harris County has gotten better. I was surprised to learn that Lina Hidalgo was barely 30 and younger than me when she started as county judge. I had low expectations of her but now I see that Harris County has received a much higher quality leadership from her than expected.

My point in saying this that both Lina and Kim are good people and I am honored to know them and even thank them for their service. They are not perfect people but they are on the side of the heroes and angels. In my exchanges with them I have seen it in their faces and their eyes that both want justice to be done correctly and want the best for the citizens of Harris County. I think that both of these women are doing the best that they can with what they have but we have to remember that they are humans too. I also remind the readers that we have had alot worse before in Harris County administration from embezzlers, skirt-chasers and racists (Rosenthal) in there before. In context with Lina and Kim, we do not have a bad deal.

It would be nice for them to note they are on the same side and dealing with a limited budget. It would be nice to see them cooperate more and not give any fodder for team Trump to attack with. The relationship could always use more harmony but we must remember that even the closes families on the side of the heroes are not always in agreement. I know Murray preferers to use Star Wars in his metaphors but I am going to deviate from that a little and offer up as example the hero families of the Ninja Turtles and the constant bickering between Raphael and Leonardo, the Avengers and the disagreements between Captain America and Iron Man or the Justice League and the disputes between Batman and Superman. In the end when push comes to shove they do work together for the good of the people and I know for a fact that both Kim and Lina have this ability within them.

Lee said...

I voted for and used to work for Kim Ogg when she was in private practice and still remain friends with her. I have often wondered why she wanted to become the district attorney (managing staff, paper shuffling running budgets) given her skill set. I have seen her in action and she is a great trial attorney and I believe that she belongs not in administration but on the front lines in court prosecuting our city's most violent or defending our city's most vulnerable. I feel like she had some policy changes that she wanted to make in the district attorney's office but I feel like she makes a far better trail attorney than administrator.

I have met Lina Hidalgo before and ran into her downtown last week and she has always been nice to me. One of my best friends Kathryn Kase works for her and the situation in Harris County has gotten better. I was surprised to learn that Lina Hidalgo was barely 30 and younger than me when she started as county judge. I had low expectations of her but now I see that Harris County has received a much higher quality leadership from her than expected.

My point in saying this that both Lina and Kim are good people and I am honored to know them and even thank them for their service. They are not perfect people but they are on the side of the heroes and angels. In my exchanges with them I have seen it in their faces and their eyes that both want justice to be done correctly and want the best for the citizens of Harris County. I think that both of these women are doing the best that they can with what they have but we have to remember that they are humans too. I also remind the readers that we have had alot worse before in Harris County administration from embezzlers, skirt-chasers and racists (Rosenthal) in there before. In context with Lina and Kim, we do not have a bad deal.

It would be nice for them to note they are on the same side and dealing with a limited budget. It would be nice to see them cooperate more and not give any fodder for team Trump to attack with. The relationship could always use more harmony but we must remember that even the closes families on the side of the heroes are not always in agreement. I know Murray preferers to use Star Wars in his metaphors but I am going to deviate from that a little and offer up as example the hero families of the Ninja Turtles and the constant bickering between Raphael and Leonardo, the Avengers and the disagreements between Captain America and Iron Man or the Justice League and the disputes between Batman and Superman. In the end when push comes to shove they do work together for the good of the people and I know for a fact that both Kim and Lina have this ability within them.

Lee said...

I voted for and used to work for Kim Ogg when she was in private practice and still remain friends with her. I have often wondered why she wanted to become the district attorney (managing staff, paper shuffling running budgets) given her skill set. I have seen her in action and she is a great trial attorney and I believe that she belongs not in administration but on the front lines in court prosecuting our city's most violent or defending our city's most vulnerable. I feel like she had some policy changes that she wanted to make in the district attorney's office but I feel like she makes a far better trial attorney than administrator.

I have met Lina Hidalgo before and ran into her downtown last week and she has always been nice to me. One of my best friends Kathryn Kase works for her and the situation in Harris County has gotten better. I was surprised to learn that Lina Hidalgo was barely 30 and younger than me when she started as county judge. I had low expectations of her but now I see that Harris County has received a much higher quality leadership from her than expected.

My point in saying this that both Lina and Kim are good people and I am honored to know them and even thank them for their service. They are not perfect people but they are on the side of the heroes and angels. In my exchanges with them I have seen it in their faces and their eyes that both want justice to be done correctly and want the best for the citizens of Harris County. I think that both of these women are doing the best that they can with what they have but we have to remember that they are humans too. I also remind the readers that we have had alot worse before in Harris County administration from embezzlers, skirt-chasers and racists (Rosenthal) in there before. In context with Lina and Kim, we do not have a bad deal.

It would be nice for them to note they are on the same side and dealing with a limited budget. It would be nice to see them cooperate more and not give any fodder for team Trump to attack with. The relationship could always use more harmony but we must remember that even the closes families on the side of the heroes are not always in agreement. I know Murray preferers to use Star Wars in his metaphors but I am going to deviate from that a little and offer up as example the hero families of the Ninja Turtles and the constant bickering between Raphael and Leonardo, the Avengers and the disagreements between Captain America and Iron Man or the Justice League and the disputes between Batman and Superman. In the end when push comes to shove they do work together for the good of the people and I know for a fact that both Kim and Lina have this ability within them.

Anonymous said...

Oh, you just know the person writing as Lee is a woman. What sentimental platitudes. "Seen it in their faces and eyes." Absurd sentiment in the face of better evidence.

Murray is right, even though he would hate to hear me say that. The problem is the influence of the media and other people like Mark Goldberg, as Murray mentioned.

The media presents the city's most violent to also be the city's most vulnerable. After all, it can be very frightening to imagine that one's crimes might bring reprisal and accountability.

The reason either the prosecution or defense engage in the media battle is because they want to poison the jury pool. They want to reach people with their message long before they come into the Court room. And if the prosecution is killing someone in the media, the defense will lose unless they get a lying bulldog of a lawyer who will do literally anything to win and rip the other side's balls off right back in the media.

When high profile defendants hire a media savvy attorney (whose check clears), the prosecution will lose unless they come back with the same WWF trash talk. The problem is that while we don't have a state-run media, we do have a media-run state. And the comic book readers and TV watchers will do whatever the media tells them to.

Judges could just order the parties and attorneys to shut the hell up on pain of imprisonment, but we don't have the courage to do that. Judges fear the same media too, which is almost always the reason when they willingly fail to make the correct ruling.

Ogg is clearly wrong, from an absolute standard of ethics. But she really lacks agency to do the right thing because of how rigged the system is by the lying press and the weakness and lethargy of our government to perform the basic function of using its power to secure a fair trial.

Attacking Hidalgo for saying the F word is super fake and gay. That whole episode is probably an invention deliberately contrived by Hidalgo (or a clever person) to suck all the oxygen away from her real problems. Criticism for one stupid reason is intended to cast doubt on actual valid criticisms while at the same time making her look like a persecuted and passionate fighter. Conservatives are so dumb. They will never save this country.

Lee said...

Anon 713pm

I am male. Drop the personal attacks. Gender has nothing to do with the responsibilities and conduct of public servants.

Anonymous said...

What a dishonest reply. I never attacked Hidalgo or Ogg for being women, only you. If I apologize for calling you a woman and other terrible things, will you actually address the important point that underlies what it is otherwise a petty local squabble? Ogg lacks agency to do the right thing because our society is sick. Because people are stupid and watch too much televitz.

Let me assure you for the sake of equality, my criticisms apply to women of both sexes.

Lee said...

You should apologize only if you want to be a decent human being. Otherwise do not bother.

Anonymous said...

Poster Child on how to conduct yourself at a Harris County Precinct Five Deputy/Constable's Funeral.

Lee said...

Huh? What funeral? Is one supposed to conduct themselves differently at a law enforcement funeral as opposed to other occupations?

How about human dignity provided equally to all humans?

Anonymous said...

I keep hearing rumors that Judge Genesis Draper is mulling over a run for DA. I think her biggest Hangup is the fact that if she announces she resigns her seat. Judge Draper is very defendant friendly I wonder what will happen if she gets the top job since the prosecutors job is to seek justice in all situations.

Murray Newman said...

Anon July 4,

I have heard the rumors about Judge Draper but I doubt them. She's a great judge and I would hate to see her leave the bench. I wouldn't characterize her as "defendant friendly" as much as I would say she follows the law and holds the State to its burden of proof. I agree that the prosecutor's job is to seek justice, but Kim Ogg doesn't hold up her end of the bargain when it comes up to that aspect of her job.

The 2024 Election

Monday, October 21st kicks off the Early Voting for the 2024 Election in Texas, and as always, the Harris County Criminal Justice World has ...